Dossier: Westminster, Holyrood and Brexit

Since 2014 the argument over Scotland's future has largely been an argument about the relationship between two parliaments. This dossier follows it from the No vote to the dispute over Brexit legislation.

• The road after the No vote

  The Vow, the Smith Commission, English votes for English laws and the Scotland Act 2016.

• After Brexit: why the campaign groups came back in 2017

  From the 62% Remain vote to the Section 30 request of March 2017.

• Hope over Fear and the 'power grab' argument

  The EU (Withdrawal) Bill as seen from George Square in September 2017.

• When Holyrood said no

  The 93–30 refusal of consent, the Sewel convention and the Continuity Bill.

• Civic or ethnic nationalism?

  The 2017 row over a speech in Perth, and what scholars mean by the distinction.

• The media and the independence debate

  Newspapers, broadcasters and the limits of criticism.

• A letter to America

  What Scotland's experience after 2014 suggested about organising after defeat.

• A 'new union'?

  Home rule, devo max, federalism and confederation explained.