Explainers

Scotland's two referendums, council by council: 2014 and 2016 results compared

Explainers · Published 2026-11-13 · Updated 2026-11-13

Scotland voted twice in less than two years on its place in a union: No to independence in September 2014, Remain in the European Union in June 2016. Both votes were counted in the same 32 council areas. This page sets the two results side by side, so you can see where they line up and where they do not.

In 2014, 44.7% of valid votes were for independence; only 4 areas, Dundee City, Glasgow City, North Lanarkshire and West Dunbartonshire, returned Yes majorities. In 2016, 62.0% of Scottish votes were for Remain and every council area voted Remain, from 50.1% in Moray to 74.4% in City of Edinburgh. The two maps are different: some of the strongest No areas of 2014, such as East Renfrewshire and Edinburgh, were among the strongest for Remain. That gap is what speakers at the 2017 rallies called a "tale of two referendums".

Look up a council area

Pick an area to see its two results, its rank among the 32 and the gap between its Remain and Yes shares. It is also highlighted in the chart and the table.

The two votes on one chart

Yes in 2014 against Remain in 2016, by council areaScatter plot of 32 council areas. Horizontal axis: Yes share in 2014, 30 to 60 per cent. Vertical axis: Remain share in 2016, 50 to 76 per cent. The table below gives every value.30%35%40%45%50%55%60%50%55%60%65%70%75%Yes, 2014Remain, 2016Aberdeen City: Yes 41.4%, Remain 61.1%Aberdeenshire: Yes 39.6%, Remain 55.0%Angus: Yes 43.7%, Remain 55.3%Argyll and Bute: Yes 41.5%, Remain 60.6%City of Edinburgh: Yes 38.9%, Remain 74.4%EdinburghClackmannanshire: Yes 46.2%, Remain 57.8%Dumfries and Galloway: Yes 34.3%, Remain 53.1%Dumfries and GallowayDundee City: Yes 57.3%, Remain 59.8%DundeeEast Ayrshire: Yes 47.2%, Remain 58.6%East Dunbartonshire: Yes 38.8%, Remain 71.4%East Lothian: Yes 38.3%, Remain 64.6%East Renfrewshire: Yes 36.8%, Remain 74.3%East RenfrewshireFalkirk: Yes 46.5%, Remain 56.8%Fife: Yes 45.0%, Remain 58.6%Glasgow City: Yes 53.5%, Remain 66.6%GlasgowHighland: Yes 47.1%, Remain 56.0%Inverclyde: Yes 49.9%, Remain 63.8%Midlothian: Yes 43.7%, Remain 62.1%Moray: Yes 42.4%, Remain 50.1%MorayNa h-Eileanan Siar: Yes 46.6%, Remain 55.2%North Ayrshire: Yes 49.0%, Remain 56.9%North Lanarkshire: Yes 51.1%, Remain 61.7%Orkney Islands: Yes 32.8%, Remain 63.2%Orkney IslandsPerth and Kinross: Yes 39.8%, Remain 61.1%Renfrewshire: Yes 47.2%, Remain 64.8%Scottish Borders: Yes 33.4%, Remain 58.5%Shetland Islands: Yes 36.3%, Remain 56.5%South Ayrshire: Yes 42.1%, Remain 59.0%South Lanarkshire: Yes 45.3%, Remain 63.1%Stirling: Yes 40.2%, Remain 67.7%West Dunbartonshire: Yes 54.0%, Remain 62.0%West Lothian: Yes 44.8%, Remain 58.3%
Each dot is a council area; dots in the accent colour voted Yes in 2014. Areas to the right voted more strongly for independence, areas higher up more strongly for Remain. The dashed line marks 50% Yes.

There is no straight line from one vote to the other. Glasgow, Dundee, North Lanarkshire and West Dunbartonshire, the four Yes areas, sit in the middle of the Remain range. The highest Remain shares came from Edinburgh, East Renfrewshire and East Dunbartonshire, which voted No in 2014 by wide margins. Moray, where the Remain majority was narrowest (50.1%), voted No by 58% in 2014; Dumfries and Galloway, one of the strongest No areas, had the second-lowest Remain share.

All 32 areas

Shares are of valid votes, computed from the vote counts; turnout is as published. Use the column buttons to sort, for example by the gap between the two votes.

Results by council area. The header buttons sort the table.
Aberdeen City41.481.761.167.9+19.7
Aberdeenshire39.687.255.070.6+15.4
Angus43.785.755.368.0+11.6
Argyll and Bute41.588.260.673.1+19.1
City of Edinburgh38.984.474.472.9+35.5
Clackmannanshire46.288.657.867.2+11.6
Dumfries and Galloway34.387.553.171.4+18.7
Dundee City57.378.859.862.9+2.4
East Ayrshire47.284.558.662.9+11.4
East Dunbartonshire38.891.071.475.1+32.6
East Lothian38.387.664.671.7+26.3
East Renfrewshire36.890.474.376.1+37.5
Falkirk46.588.756.867.5+10.2
Fife45.084.158.666.7+13.6
Glasgow City53.575.066.656.2+13.1
Highland47.187.056.071.6+8.9
Inverclyde49.987.463.866.0+13.9
Midlothian43.786.862.168.1+18.4
Moray42.485.450.167.4+7.7
Na h-Eileanan Siar46.686.255.270.1+8.7
North Ayrshire49.084.456.964.6+7.9
North Lanarkshire51.184.461.760.9+10.6
Orkney Islands32.883.763.268.3+30.4
Perth and Kinross39.886.961.173.7+21.3
Renfrewshire47.287.364.869.2+17.6
Scottish Borders33.487.458.573.4+25.0
Shetland Islands36.384.456.570.3+20.2
South Ayrshire42.186.159.069.8+16.8
South Lanarkshire45.385.363.165.3+17.8
Stirling40.290.167.774.0+27.5
West Dunbartonshire54.087.962.063.9+8.0
West Lothian44.886.258.367.6+13.4
Scotland44.784.662.067.2+17.3

The referendums asked different questions, of slightly different electorates: 16- and 17-year-olds and most EU citizens resident in Scotland could vote in 2014, but not in 2016. Our explainers on why the campaign groups came back after Brexit and on the 2018 dispute over legislative consent follow what happened next.

Method, sources and licence

Data. Counts of Yes and No votes, valid votes and turnout for 2014 come from the results table of the Wikipedia article "2014 Scottish independence referendum" (revision 1380059721 of 13 October 2026); Remain and Leave votes and turnout for 2016 from "Results of the 2016 United Kingdom European Union membership referendum" (revision 1373196891 of 4 September 2026). Both were read on 13 November 2026: 32 council areas, 64 results. Those tables reproduce the official results declared by the counting officers and published by the Electoral Commission (2014 referendum, 2016 referendum).

Checks. The council totals add up to the national figures: 1,617,989 Yes and 2,001,926 No in 2014; 1,661,191 Remain and 1,018,322 Leave in Scotland in 2016. The Scotland turnout figures (84.6% and 67.2%) are the published national ones. Percentages are recomputed from the vote counts and rounded to one decimal, so they can differ by 0.1 point from figures quoted elsewhere. Council names follow the 2016 list (for example "Glasgow City", "Na h-Eileanan Siar").

Licence. Wikipedia text and tables are available under CC BY-SA 4.0; the official results are Crown copyright and may be reused under the Open Government Licence v3.0. This table and chart are shared under CC BY-SA 4.0. Sorting and look-up run in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere.